Rethinking the Dog Park: Why It Might Not Be Best for Your Dog
Dog parks have long been seen as the popular spot to take our dogs for socializing and exercise. However, as a dog trainer and behaviorist, I can tell you that it is doing more harm than good to rely on the dog park for your dog's entertainment. Here's why:
1. Reinforcing Bad Behaviors: It doesn't matter if your dog is the most well-behaved, confident, and friendly pup in the pack; we cannot control the behaviors of other dogs in the dog park, and that is what will end up influencing your dog's behavior. Barks, growls, and scuffles are inevitable as your dog tries to navigate the social dynamics of the park, and how they decide to respond to these overwhelming interactions may not be what you were expecting. Not to mention how dogs will interact with the people there; jumping up, running full speed into their legs, barking, ignoring their owner, I've even seen dogs lift their leg on a stranger... no thanks! This environment does not always foster good behavior and positive interactions. Instead, the dog park can inadvertently reinforce the negative behaviors in your dog.
2. Health Risks: With so many dogs coming and going and no requirement for vaccines or parasite preventatives, dog parks are a common breeding ground for all manner of parasites and diseases. From fleas to more serious ailments like parvovirus and kennel cough, the risk of exposure to these health hazards increases dramatically in these crowded park settings. Shared water bowls, toys, swimming pools, and nose-to-nose (or in some cases, nose-to-butt) contact provide many opportunities for those nasty, microscopic viruses and parasitic critters to climb aboard onto our dogs. No thanks!
3. Anxiety Amplifier: For dogs predisposed to anxiety or fear, the hustle and bustle of the dog park can be overwhelming. The onslaught of unfamiliar sights, sounds, and smells can trigger stress rather than enjoyment, leaving your dog feeling insecure and on edge. Too often I see nervous dogs getting bombarded by other dogs and their owners do NOTHING to advocate for their space. The dogs are usually hiding next to their owner; looking for security, and any trust they might have in their human quickly unravels when the owner provides no reprieve or protection from the intrusive dogs.
4. Lack of Control: The most common pattern I see at dog parks: the dogs are barking or whining in the car upon arrival, they pull on the leash all the way to the gates, dogs rush in to overwhelm them once through the gates, then owners release the dog and relinquish control over their dog's interactions and surroundings. Not only are we reinforcing these behavior patterns each time we do this, but we are showing our dogs that we are not a leader. Dogs are pack animals, and thrive with direction and leadership. When they do not get that from us, how can we expect to them to care about anything we say or ask them to do? Most of the tension between dogs at the dog park is due to dogs trying to establish a hierarchy of pack order. The battle for control is usually sorted in less desirable ways, which is why we see so many scuffs and fights in dog parks.
5. Unpredictable Encounters: Every dog is unique, and you never quite know what personalities your dog might encounter at the park. From overly exuberant dogs, to the stand off-ish less social dogs, the potential for unpredictable and potentially risky encounters is highly likely.
Let's Imagine some scenarios (inspired from scenes I've seen frequently at the dog park):
1. Resource Guarding Encounter: Jane took her friendly Pitty mix, Max, to the local dog park for his daily exercise, and she brought the ball because he loves fetch. Everything seemed fine until another dog, a possessive ball-driven German Shepherd, also wanted to chase the ball and would try to herd and harass Max whenever Max had the ball. During an instance where they both arrived at the ball at the same time and Max grabbed it, the German Shepherd snapped at him to claim the ball and Max had enough. In a matter of seconds, it escalated into a full-blown fight over the ball, leaving both dogs with minor injuries and Jane shaken by the sudden aggression in Max. She tried to defend Max from the still persistent German Shepherd as its owner was across the park calling the shepherd (with no response). When the owner finally arrived to remove his dog, the Shepherd started playing keep-away and would not get within reach of his owner. Jane left the park with an injured Max, and the Shepherd continued to roam the park harassing other dogs.
2. The Overwhelmed Dog: Bob thought a trip to the dog park would be the perfect way to socialize his new rescue dog, Bella, who seemed nervous about other dogs, so he wanted to get her more comfortable. However, as soon as they entered the busy park, Bella's tail tucked between her legs, and she cowered behind Mike, overwhelmed by the chaos around her. Mike tried to push her out closer to other dogs to encourage her to "go play" and separated himself from Bella. Bella remained visibly distressed, her anxiety only intensifying with each passing minute, and learned that her owner was not someone she could look to for protection or guidance. This situation may end in a couple of ways: the other dogs will either lose interest in Bella and leave her alone, or they will gang up to harass her because they will sense weakness and insecurity. Bella will then have to chose between fight or flight because her owner is not advocating for her space or safety.
3. The Misinterpreted Play: Sarah became instantly shocked as her normally well-behaved Border Collie, Charlie, attacked another dog at the dog park. Unbeknownst to Sarah, Charlie's herding instincts kicked in when a smaller dog got the zoomies and started sprinting around him, triggering his innate desire to chase and control. The owners of both dogs considered it a game of chase and were thrilled to see their dogs getting so much exercise. However, when the smaller dog became insecure and tucked his tail to disengage from the chase, three other dogs had joined in the chase and tackled him. As soon as the small dog yelped in a panic, it triggered Charlie's prey drive and he aggressively pinned the small dog, attempting to nip and bite as the little dog yelped for help. The small dog's owner picked up their dog, but Charlie continued to circle and bark at the small dog in it's owners arms leading to a tense confrontation between owners and an abrupt end to their park visit. Charlie left and learned how fun it was to chase and go after other dogs, while the small dog went on to become insecure and reactive when other dogs get too close.
These stories serve as reminders that even well-intentioned trips to the dog park can quickly go downhill due to unpredictable interactions, owner's lack of control of their dogs, and a misunderstanding of dog behavior and body language that most people do not recognize.
Instead of relying on the dog park for your dog's socialization and exercise needs, consider these alternative activities that will greatly benefit you, your dog, and your bond:
1. Structured Walks: Take your dog on walks in new environments and practice your training on the leash (recall, loose leash, engagement). Start with more controlled environments where they can easily focus on you, then increase the distractions in the environment. This will be monumental for building a great relationship with your dog where they can focus on you and remain neutral in any environment.
2. Training Time: Get a head start to setting your dog up for success. Enroll your dog in training or practice training on your own to establish healthy routines, boundaries, and start building a better relationship with your dog. Teach them how fun YOU are!
3. Mental stimulation: Stimulate your dog's mind with enrichment activities like scent work: hide some high value treats/toys in various locations and assign them a "find-it" command! Practice impulse control while they are on place, practice threshold boundaries when opening doors, etc. (all of this requires them to slow down and THINK!)
4. Socialization: A common misconception is that your dog must meet and physically interact with as many people and dogs as possible (hence the dog park conundrum). In all actuality, socialization should look like: arranged walks or outings with known, well-behaved canine companions in settings where you can control and oversee interactions and ensure a positive experience and respectful interactions for all involved. Socialization can also involve taking your dog to new environments and teaching them to be neutral around dogs, people, and kids. Teaching your dog to focus on you in any environment is incredibly valuable and rewarding for both sides of the leash. As you properly socialize your dog, make positive associations with all of the above! Incorporate rewards, play, and affection for good behaviors.
5. Physical Fulfillment: Explore forms of physical activity that your dog is naturally interested in, such as hiking, chasing the ball, swimming, pulling you on your bike or skis, or organized canine sports like agility or fastCAT, where safety and controlled environments take precedence. Not only are these fun for your dog, but they will bond with you even more since you are the one who is interacting with them in these 1:1 activities and proving how fun YOU can be above all else.
In summary, while the dog park may seem like the go-to option for canine recreation, it's important to weigh the pros and cons that can ultimately change your dog's behavior. By opting for alternative activities that prioritize safety, control, and 1:1 engagement with YOU, you can provide your dog with enriching experiences that foster growth and well-being without the uncertainties of the dog park environment.
Comments